How To Check Your Life Insurer's Health

By Kathy Kristof, Tribune Media Services
San Jose (CA) Mercury News
July 5, 2009

If you want to know why it's important to know the health of your life insurance company, ask Vince Watson. His daughter, Katie, was left severely disabled and in need of 24-hour care because of a series of tragic errors at a hospital.

The hospital purchased a life insurance policy that was supposed to pay for Katie's care for the rest of her life. But less than a decade later, the insurance company failed and the Watsons learned a hard lesson about the limits on life insurance company guaranty funds.

The monthly annuity payments that were supposed to pay for Katie's care were cut in half. The home that they'd built to accommodate a hospital wing for Katie was foreclosed on. The Watsons filed for bankruptcy protection. The family believes that they are millions of dollars poorer because of the failure.

And Vince Watson, 68, says that although he can make sure Katie is well cared for while he's alive, he's not sure whether there will be enough money to cover her needs when he and his wife are gone.

"We have a tremendous feeling of betrayal whenever people say that policyholders are fine (in a failure) and are made whole," Watson said from his home in Phoenix. "Katie and our family have been through a lot because of this problem."

Today's miserable economy makes it more important than ever for policyholders to check what's backing their insurance policies, said Martin Weiss, author of "The Ultimate Depression Survival Guide" and president of Weiss Research in Jupiter, Fla.

That's because insurance claims rise and investment returns fall in a bad economy. That combination might not topple a company right away, but it can severely weaken it, leaving it vulnerable to failure later, Weiss said.

A rash of failures

Indeed, the last great recession was in the early 1980s. About a decade later, there was a rash of insurance company failures, including Executive Life Insurance of California the Watsons' insurer American Integrity Insurance and Andrew Jackson Life, according to the National Organization of Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Associations.

Because life insurance contracts are often long-term commitments you make to ensure that your family doesn't face economic collapse, it's important to understand what would happen if the company that backs you were to fail. As the Watsons learned the hard way, the answer isn't always pretty.

How well you fare in an insurance company collapse will vary greatly depending on the type of policy you hold.

Some types of insurance policies variable annuities, for example have a structure that protects investors, Weiss said. That's because the investment portion of the annuity is in a trust that's likely to be managed by a separate investment company. In an insurance company failure, you would get those assets back without limitation. (Whether a variable annuity is a good investment is another story.)

That's not the case if you own a large term or whole life policy, a so-called universal life policy, a fixed-rate annuity or a guaranteed investment contract. In the event of a failure, claims on these policies would be paid by a state guaranty association if they're paid at all. And guaranty association coverage is not as simple or standard as the insurance coverage provided to bank accounts through the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.

Although there are some national standards, coverage backing insurance policies is set on a state-by-state basis. In some instances, it can be tough to determine which state's fund might cover you.

Typically, insurance guaranty associations cover up to $300,000 in death benefits, up to $100,000 in cash-surrender values on whole and universal life policies and up to $100,000 in the present value of an annuity, said Peter Gallanis, president of the National Organization of Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Associations.

But that varies. California's guaranty association essentially imposes a deductible, saying it will pay the lesser of 80 percent of the failed insurer's contractual obligation or up to $250,000 in death benefits. It will also pay up to $100,000 in cash-surrender or withdrawal values.

Check your coverage

New Jersey, on the other hand, provides up to $500,000 in coverage for death benefits and annuity payments, without the deductible. Arizona's guaranty association fits neatly into the industry standard up to $300,000 in death benefits and $100,000 for annuities and cash value but it doesn't pay for guaranteed investment contracts at all.

Generally speaking, you would be covered by the guaranty association in the state where you reside. However, if you bought an insurance policy through a company pension plan as some people buy guaranteed investment contracts through a 401(k) you could be covered by the association in the state where the plan is domiciled, Gallanis said.

You can find the coverage limitations of any guaranty association at Click on "facts & figures" and then on "guaranty association laws," where you can look up the rules by state.

How do you check the health of your insurer? Your agent should be willing to provide a litany of insurance ratings from the likes of A.M. Best, Moody's and Standard & Poor's.

However, Weiss suggests that you also check the ratings at . The reason: These ratings are fully independent and compiled using data filed with regulators. The other rating services are paid for their ratings by the rated companies. Insurers sometimes pull their information and go "unrated" if they don't like what's said.

To find insurers' ratings at, go to "portfolio & tools" and click on "insurance and HMO ratings."

You can search by company if you already have an insurer and just want to know its rating, or you can search by state, which will give you a list of all the insurers licensed to operate and their ratings. Weiss suggests you check the ratings at least once annually and do business only with A- and B-rated companies.
Copyright © 2009 FBIC (

Click here to return to FBIC homepage